Side by side
AI Reply by ReplyReviews vs MagicReply
Compare what each tool does, what it costs, and how it fits your workflow.
Designed for
Automate professional replies to Google reviews with AI.
Generate professional replies to public reviews with AI
Primary task
Customer review replies
Customer review replies
Pricing
Paid · from $11.68
Free Trial · Trial; then from $19.99/mo
Pricing details
from $11.68
Free + from $19.99/mo
Billing cycle
One-time
Monthly
API access
Not documented
Not documented
Platforms
Chrome Extension
Web, Chrome Extension
Integrations
Telegram, Chrome
X / Twitter, LinkedIn
Source rating
No rating recorded
No rating recorded
Catalog views
627
999
Estimated monthly traffic
—
—
Catalog imported
30 Aug 2026
30 Aug 2026
Listed strengths
- Chrome extension
- Automates response creation
- Automates response publishing
- Personalized replies
- Tailored to each review
- Supports various platforms
- Provides reply tone options
- Provides reply length options
- User-friendly interface
- Proactive review management
Listed limitations
- Limited to Chrome extension
- Only Google reviews supported
- Purchases require credits
- No expiry on credits may imply non-refundable
- Unidentified developer
- Limited free generations
- Doesn't guarantee reply accuracy
- Relies on user review/edit
- No direct reply integration
- Potential defamation/misinterpretation risks